Nanotube defects may cut fuel cell costs

Carbon nanotubes with imperfections could replace the pricey catalysts that have kept fuel cells from widespread use. Multi-walled carbon nanotubes riddled with defects and impurities on the outside could eventually replace some of the expensive platinum catalysts used in fuel cells and metal-air batteries, such as those used in fuel-cell cars, according to Stanford University scientists. Their findings are published in the May 27 online edition of the journal Nature Nanotechnology. “Platinum is very expensive and thus impractical for large-scale commercialization,” says Hongjie Dai, a professor of chemistry and co-author of the study. “Developing a low-cost alternative has been a major research goal for several decades.” Over the past five years, the price of platinum has ranged from just below $800 to more than $2,200 an ounce. Among the most promising low-cost alternatives to platinum is the carbon nanotube—a rolled-up sheet of pure carbon, called graphene, that’s one atom thick and more than 10,000 times narrower than a human hair. Carbon nanotubes and graphene are excellent conductors of electricity and relatively inexpensive to produce. For the study, the team used multi-walled carbon nanotubes consisting of two or three concentric tubes nested together. The scientists showed that shredding the outer wall, while leaving the inner walls intact, enhances catalytic activity in nanotubes, yet does not interfere with their ability to conduct electricity. “A typical carbon nanotube has few defects,” says Yanguang Li, a postdoctoral fellow and lead author of the study. “But defects are actually important to promote the formation of catalytic sites and to render the nanotube very active for catalytic reactions.” Unzipped For the study, Li and his co-workers treated multi-walled nanotubes in a chemical solution. Microscopic analysis revealed that the treatment caused the outer nanotube to partially unzip and form nanosized graphene pieces that clung to the inner nanotube, which remained mostly intact. “We found that adding a few iron and nitrogen impurities made the outer wall very active for catalytic reactions,” Dai says. “But the inside maintained its integrity, providing a path for electrons to move around. You want the outside to be very active, but you still want to have good electrical conductivity. If you used a single-wall carbon nanotube you wouldn’t have this advantage, because the damage on the wall would degrade the electrical property.” In fuel cells and metal-air batteries, platinum catalysts play a crucial role in speeding up the chemical reactions that convert hydrogen and oxygen to water. But the partially unzipped, multi-walled nanotubes might work just as well, Li adds. “We found that the catalytic activity of the nanotubes is very close to platinum,” he says. “This high activity and the stability of the design make them promising candidates for fuel cells.” The researchers recently sent samples of the experimental nanotube catalysts to fuel cell experts for testing. “Our goal is to produce a fuel cell with very high energy density that can last very long,” Li says. Multi-walled nanotubes could also have applications in metal-air batteries made of lithium or zinc. “Lithium-air batteries are exciting because of their ultra-high theoretical energy density, which is more than 10 times higher than today’s best lithium ion technology,” Dai says. “But one of the stumbling blocks to development has been the lack of a high-performance, low-cost catalyst. Carbon nanotubes could be an excellent alternative to the platinum, palladium, and other precious-metal catalysts now in use.” Controversial sites The study might also have resolved a long-standing scientific controversy about the chemical structure of catalytic active sites where oxygen reactions occur. “One group of scientists believes that iron impurities are bonded to nitrogen at the active site,” Li says. “Another group believes that iron contributes virtually nothing, except to promote active sites made entirely of nitrogen.” To address the controversy, the team enlisted scientists at Oak Ridge National Laboratory to conduct atomic-scale imaging and spectroscopy analysis of the nanotubes. The results showed clear, visual evidence of iron and nitrogen atoms in close proximity. “For the first time, we were able to image individual atoms on this kind of catalyst,” Dai says. “All of the images showed iron and nitrogen close together, suggesting that the two elements are bonded. This kind of imaging is possible, because the graphene pieces are just one atom thick.” Dai notes that the iron impurities, which enhanced catalytic activity, actually came from metal seeds that were used to make the nanotubes and were not intentionally added by the scientists. The discovery of these accidental yet invaluable bits of iron offered the researchers an important lesson. “We learned that metal impurities in nanotubes must not be ignored,” Dai says. Other co-authors of the study contributed from Stanford University, Vanderbilt University and Oak Ridge National Laboratory, and Tsinghua University in China. This work was supported, in part, by a grant from the Precourt Institute for Energy at Stanford, Intel, Lawrence Berkeley and Oak Ridge national laboratories, the Department of Energy, and the National Science Foundation.