A US appeals court threw out Thursday a multi-million dollar award against toymaker Matell in a long-running dispute with a rival over Bratz children's dolls. Matell was ordered to pay its competitor MGA Entertainment $170 million in 2011, along with nearly $140 million in legal fees, in the dispute over ownership claims for the lucrative doll line aimed at pre-teen girls. But the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the claim was improperly litigated, so it quashed the verdict -- and urged both sides to "play nice." MGA launched Bratz dolls in June 2001 and they quickly became the top competitor to Matell's world-famous Barbie, racking up more than $1 billion in annual sales and cutting into Mattel's market dominance with Barbie. In a first trial in 2008, a jury sided with Mattel and awarded $100 million in damages. MGA was ordered to turn over the franchise to Mattel and stop making and selling Bratz products -- but the order was overturned on appeal and sent back for a retrial. Mattel argued that Carter Bryant, Bratz's creator and a former Barbie designer, invented the dolls in 1999 during his second stint with the company and that he violated the terms of his employment by taking his ideas to MGA. MGA, meanwhile, accused Mattel of spying on its rivals, including using false identification cards to enter the MGA premises to photograph its products without authorization. A jury also last year rejected copyright infringement claims by Matell against MGA Entertainment, and awarded MGA $88.4 million in damages. Thursday's ruling appears unlikely to be the end of the legal war -- even if the federal appelate panel cautioned the rival toymakers against throwing any new judicial tantrums. "While this may not be the last word on the subject, perhaps Mattel and MGA can take a lesson from their target demographic: Play nice," it said.
GMT 17:19 2018 Thursday ,11 January
China factory gate inflation slows to 13-month lowGMT 17:50 2018 Wednesday ,10 January
German industrial output rebounds in NovemberGMT 17:39 2018 Wednesday ,10 January
Samsung tips record Q4 operating profit of more than $14 bnGMT 17:29 2018 Tuesday ,09 January
German industrial orders dip in NovemberGMT 15:36 2018 Thursday ,04 January
China factory activity accelerated in December: CaixinGMT 13:33 2018 Wednesday ,03 January
Turkey inflation rate eases but still stubbornly high in DecemberGMT 16:27 2018 Monday ,01 January
China manufacturing activity slows in DecemberGMT 17:36 2017 Sunday ,31 December
Spain to leave EU's deficit 'sin bin' next year: Rajoy
Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2025 ©
Maintained and developed by Arabs Today Group SAL.
All rights reserved to Arab Today Media Group 2025 ©
Send your comments
Your comment as a visitor